← All work

Google MyMaps Design Challenge

This UX audit and redesign focuses on Google’s outdated MyMaps, a low-engagement tool with untapped potential within the Google Maps ecosystem.

Project

A product design challenge

Disciplines

Product design · UX

UI/UX design challenge Google
My Maps
Designed by Vicent Koh
Desktop redesign with separate Locations and Routes panels. Mobile redesign with a locations list in a bottom sheet.

The challenge

Google MyMaps allows users to make maps with customised markers and routes. They can add descriptions and pictures to describe a specific markers, and draw perimeters, define a specific routes to follow from marker to marker via a drawn route. There are also advanced function that allows uploading of a spreadsheet formatted file to visualise markers on the map.

From my research, some of the users that finds the concept of the app useful to them includes:

  • Travellers who need to plan their trip and places to visit
  • Biking enthusiast who explore forest trails and require custom maps for waypoints not covered traditionally by Google Maps.

However, Google MyMaps faces many UX issues that limits its competitiveness in the market, especially with competitors offering better platform compatibility and features.

What users told us

With three days for the challenge, I focused on secondary research to understand how people use MyMaps and where they get stuck.

When performing the research, here are the following constraints I encountered:

  • There is a lack of official platforms for review. Unlike native iOS or Android apps where there is a review section to gather feedbacks, this app exist purely on web only.

However, I managed to find discussion about MyMaps through forums such as Reddit and a biking community discussion forum, and there are multiple users sharing what they like and dislike about the app.

I gathered about 7–9 useful comments across the discussions.

What worked

  • Customisable, maps with personalised content, good for planning trips with routes.
  • Uploading of KML files allow for mapping of routes from other softwares.

Where people struggled

  • Outdated and different from the Google ecosystem UX and Visual Design.
  • Limited to only 10 layers per map, adds up fast when adding multiple routes.
  • No link between google maps and my maps, and not having the advantage Google Maps have to offer (route suggestions, public transport and timings)
  • Not having navigation guidance for custom roads plotted in MyMap.

Extra Note: Google maps allow similar function in terms of plotting location (point equivalent in mymaps), but routes are predetermined.

What the audit found

AreaWhat I foundDesign implication
Adding and managing locations
  • Customisable selection of colors and icons for points, improve design semantics.
  • Its not clear how to add new markers, poor discoverability.
  • Pressing X removes entry name instead of the entry itself.
Keep custom colors and icons. Make Add location visible and give deletion its own clearly labelled control.
Editing routes
  • Layers are effective in customising route and point options (Eg. Travel itinerary A vs B, where there may be similar points but different routes.)
  • Could not find a way to delete paths.
  • Add direction creates a new automated route by default, but is grouped differently from route adding section
  • Route creation menu is called “Draw a Line” which is confusing.
Keep layers for alternate itineraries. Bring route creation into one Routes panel, replace “Draw a Line” with a clearer label, and make route deletion easy to find.
Sharing places
  • No means of sharing points of interest with others.
Explore a way to share individual points of interest.
Using the map on mobile
  • Poor optimisation for mobile, menu is taking up too much space on mobile screen and it needs to be used often.
  • Navigation guide for when using the map while on a journey.
  • Track live location on mobile, allowing addition of current location and route via GPS.
Move frequently used tools into a bottom sheet to keep the map visible. Explore navigation guidance and GPS-based editing in a future iteration.
Planning travel
  • Integration with Google Maps for suggested routes, including public transport routes.
Explore Google Maps integration for route suggestions, including public transport.

Choosing what to redesign

I ranked improvements by user impact and implementation complexity. Issues that appeared in both the research and the audit, or blocked a core task, received higher priority.

Feature priority by importance and complexity
ImportanceLow complexityHigh complexity
High importance
  • Improving UI Discoverability
  • No ways to share point of interest
  • Redundant Add Direction Button (Integrate with other routes)
  • No clear way to delete routes in UI
  • UX Writing Improvement
  • UI Refresh
  • Integration with Google Maps on Navigation
  • Mobile Friendliness (With Integration of Mobile Interactions)
  • Improve shape drawing mechanics
Low importance
  • Social Engagement Features
  • Live GPS marker and route addition
  • Custom Route Navigation on Mobile
  • Ability to add points & routes via live tracking on mobile
  • Social map functions (Community engagement, curated content)

For the redesign, I focused on these changes:

  • Improve UI Discoverability
  • UI Refresh (Based off latest Google UI and Material 3 UI Library)
  • Mobile Friendly Design
  • UX Writing Improvement
  • Clearer way to delete routes
  • Redesign of Route Adding mechanics

A clearer way to make a map

The redesign uses Material 3 to bring the interface closer to the rest of Google’s products. It separates locations from routes and makes the next action easier to find.

Keep locations and routes separate

The search bar keeps map-wide controls within reach. Separate Locations and Routes panels make add and sort easier to find, while a bin icon distinguishes delete from rename. Selecting a route shows the path, travel mode, and distance between stops.

Desktop overview with separate Locations and Routes panels and the selected route on the map.
Desktop overview with separate Locations and Routes panels and the selected route on the map.

Make editing a distinct mode

Adding or editing a route opens a toolbar with travel options and undo and redo. Guidance on the map explains which action to take next.

Route editing with a floating toolbar and travel options.
Route editing with a floating toolbar and travel options.

Make the path easier to trace

The map dims while you draw so the route and cursor stand out. Tracing completes when the cursor reaches the final marker, so you can start the next segment from that point.

Manual tracing with a dimmed map and highlighted path.
Manual tracing with a dimmed map and highlighted path.

Offer a dynamic route

Choose endpoints and a preferred mode of travel. The proposed Google Maps integration could use live traffic and public transport availability to suggest a route.

Dynamic route preview with confirmation controls.
Dynamic route preview with confirmation controls.

Separate map settings from everyday tools

The search bar opens a dedicated menu for actions such as opening, copying, and exporting a map. Move to Trash sits apart from the other actions.

Map management menu with Move to Trash separated at the bottom.
Map management menu with Move to Trash separated at the bottom.

Planning on the go

On mobile, locations and routes move into a bottom sheet so the map stays in view.

Keep the map visible

A bottom sheet keeps locations within reach while leaving roughly half the screen available for panning and navigating.

Locations with a bottom sheet
Locations with a bottom sheet

Switch between locations and routes

The toggle gives each task its own view. Switch to Routes to manage travel between stops, or return to Locations to manage markers.

Routes in a separate tab
Routes in a separate tab

Move the map under a fixed cursor

While tracing, the cursor stays centered as the map moves beneath it. Tools stay around the map so there is room to see the surrounding area.

Route tracing with a centered cursor
Route tracing with a centered cursor

Keep occasional actions in the side menu

With locations and routes in the bottom sheet, the side menu is available for less frequent tasks such as printing, exporting, and managing maps.

Map management menu
Map management menu

What I’d refine next

This design challenge really reflects a realistic scenario of working in a product team, where sometimes there is need to push a new feature or design quickly.

While I have many ideas, I soon realise I may not have that much time to complete the designs, especially since mobile responsiveness is a big part of the redesign in my opinion. Hence, I chose to focus on what I evaluated as the most important.

As a result, the solution and mockups targets a limited scope of pages, primarily those involve in the main user flow, along with a visual concept for the UI.

Personally, I felt that some areas of the user flow could be further refined, and my next stages of progress with more time would be designing the dialogs for adding new locations and the incorporation of live navigation features.